Michael
488 reviews270 followers
Written by a Professor of Psychiatry who studied people who said they had encounters with alien beings, this is the outcome of him listening to their stories and taking them seriously. It's a collection of various stories and regressions of people who claim to have been abducted. There's a lot more to this book though, it goes deep psychologically and spiritually. A must read if you're interested or aware of this phenomena, it's the best one I've read.
Sue
1,698 reviews1 follower
Really good.
It was scary and one night I had to discontinue because I was really creeped out.
I was hearing noises in the house and thought the aliens were coming through the walls; only the cats. ok.
- esoteric
Doris Jean
196 reviews31 followers
I did not like this book. There is nothing wrong with the book, it's just that I personally did not like it. (The author is a fully qualified psychiatrist at Harvard who has won a Pulitzer Prize for his book on T. E. Lawrence.) This book was well done, well organized, used good fluent language and good physical paper and bonding. It was a detailed recounting of thirteen or so case histories of alien abductees. Some had families and children who were also abductees. These abductees were normal psychologically without any psychological co-morbidities. The book was technically good and had "References" and an "Index". Flying saucers have always interested me. The subject of people who believe that they are alien abductees is interesting to me. I have met a few abductees, but in this book I didn't learn anything. I didn't see any discussion of the psychology of this phenomenon. The content of this book was, to me, boring and uneventful and uninformative. These abductees were mostly taken by the little gray men with pointy black eyes to a silver spaceship with blue lights where they had their anuses, vaginas, penises and the like penetrated and their body fluids sampled. They had their sperm and ova taken to make hybrids. Some of the abductees believed that they were hybrids themselves. Many of the abductees hinted that they were special in some way. There were no psychological and no spiritual epiphanies for me to learn. And that was it for about 432 pages.
Patrick
35 reviews1 follower
Although unwilling to try and define their exact nature, John Mack believes that abduction experiences are real, and he writes to persuade his readers to reconsider their Western, materialistic worldview that results in a dismissive attitude toward the phenomenon. Mack was a Harvard professor and psychiatrist who had his own worldview altered as a result of his work with abductees. The bulk of the book consists of case studies of abductees (one per chapter). Mack begins each of these with a brief bio of the person, followed by detailed accounts of his or her sessions with Mack during which, through hypnosis, they experience "regressions" that unearth hitherto repressed memories of encounters with entities not of this world. One might wonder how easily Mack slept at night given the disturbing and bizarre experiences he saw his patients re-live in his office. The book was interesting, disturbing, and worldview-bending. I did grow weary at points of the abductees' attempts to communicate what they obviously felt was beyond their ability (or even human language) to communicate, but Mack's summaries were helpful in bringing some clarity.
- nonfiction
Dawn Reynolds
5 reviews2 followers
I would read this book in the evening as I was waiting to fall asleep. This book is great if you want to scare the crap out of yourself when the lights are off. Its been a couple of years since I read this, but I do remember being too afraid to go to the bathroom at 3am. I was convinced that there would be an alien somewhere waiting for me and I would never be the same. Scared the crap outta me. Great book. ♡♡♡
Claire
61 reviews
This book is much more analytical and in-depth than others of this type; Dr. Mack is a Harvard Pulitzer Prize winner who documents his cases meticulously. CAUTION: Read in small doses----it gets creepy after a while, but remains fascinating!!
Iona Stewart
833 reviews270 followers
This is an excellent work that will convince everyone of the existence of extra-terrestrials, wherever they come from. We are given detailed accounts by specific persons who have been visited by these beings. It turned out that most of them perhaps all had been visited by them from an extremely early age, though it was not until much later that they realized this. The experiencers underwent hypnosis/regression to aid them to recall the incidents in detail. They were taken up to the extra-terrestrials’ ships and were there exposed to intrusive physical investigations of their sexual organs and anus. These were both unpleasant and painful. Sperm was taken from the men and, as far as I recall, eggs taken from the women. Later, some experienced seeing many strange-looking babies which they were told were their own. Despite the unpleasant examinations, the abductees were told that the extra-terrestrials were doing these for positive reasons, i.e. that of trying to improve us humans physically and also to develop us personally and spiritually. The extra-terrestrials are “more advanced spiritually and emotionally than we are”. One of the salient points that emerged was that several of those interviewed felt they knew the extra-terrestrials from before and, in particular, felt that they themselves were one of them - that they were themselves in part extra-terrestrial. Those interviewed experienced spiritual development following the experiences. One, Joe, felt “the fragmented parts” of himself coming together and an increase in “my soul’s love and energy”. He experienced a male-female integration. We are given thirteen in-depth case histories of alien abductions. The various abductees confirm each others’stories. I am in no doubt as to the veracity of these accounts. The accounts are extremely comprehensive; in fact if the book has a negative side to it, it is that there are so many in-depth comprehensive accounts, more than necessary. But I híghly recommend the book to all those attracted to the subject.
Meg
241 reviews29 followers
The first thought after finishing the last sentence was, "Thank god that is finished!". In all honesty, if I could it would be a 2.5, the .5 coming from the last chapter in which Dr. Mack recovers by adding some sanity to the book. I expected this book to be more critical than what it was, especially for a Harvard professor.
The book is compromised of mostly abduction stories and for me 13 was too many. My two qualms about the book were that Mack used hypnotic regression and his insistance on the lack of pathology. Hypnotic regression is at best a controversial technique due to ease of suggestions and the accuracy of the information. Secondly even though Mack says there is no pathology in these patients I would contend a vast majority had life events and traumas in which an abduction story would be something they could believe. Especially the clients who had unfavorable childhoods or had a difficult time fitting in.
I believe that seeing the emotional response of his clients during these hypnotic sessions led Mack to believe there was something more. In fact, he kind of admits to that in the last chapter.
What saved this from a one star rating was he did have a couple interesting points and observations. I have no doubt that the feelings of the experiencers are no doubt real. And most pyschologists that have studied them suggest there is something there. But I am not convinced that this is more than a mental pathology.
If you are looking for a book that gives an objective or critical critique of the abduction phenomenon you can pass this book up.
- alternative
Erik Graff
5,098 reviews1,301 followers
Frankly, I find psychological case studies boring in general. The few exceptions have been book-length studies by exceptionally good writers. Mack is all right as a writer, but not exceptional, not here. The theme of these case studies carried me through the exercise, however. The facts that a tenured senior psychiatrist at Harvard, a psychoanalytically trained Pulitzer winner, would give credence to alien abduction accounts by his clients, that there were so many so accounts available to him in his practice, certainly grabbed my attention. In fairness, Mack walks a fine line between giving credence to his subjects, most of whom were quite shaken by their experiences, and making any claims about the objective events, if any, behind them. He does not claim that aliens are visiting Earth aboard spaceships, abducting humans to subject them to medical experimentation and the occasional elevating lecture-demonstration about global ecology. He does note, however, that such are the characteristic reports and that the reporters evince great seriousness and no mental disorders.
- psychology
Jackee
29 reviews6 followers
I read this book as a child, because I used to be obsessed with Aliens. I didn't believe they existed, but I loved reading about them in a fictional sense. This book scared me so much (in an omg they may exist sense) that I never finished it.
Patrick\
554 reviews15 followers
Best book going on alien abductions. John Mack is no crazy pushing an agenda of proof. The accounts presented by this respected psychiatrist point out a uniformity of abuction experiences that defies rational explanation other than what they claim to be. Mass illusion? Possibly. No paranoia - no government conspiracies - straight reportage with comment. Mack leaves the abductions question open as to authenticity, though only a crack.
- paranormal science
Arthur Sperry
381 reviews11 followers
Interesting book by the Harvard Psychologist and Professor who believes that there is truth to many abduction stories. My thoughts are: If just one of these stories is true, it changes everything.
Kayla
42 reviews18 followers
WARNING: graphic mentions of sexual assault. please don't read this if it may upset you. This is not a true review, as I haven't yet finished the book. I started in December and have had some difficulty getting through it, as the book is long, dense, and repetitive. Please forgive my sloppy writing. I just wanted to get my thoughts out there for now. I went into this book with a really open mind. The first several stories were interesting and not completely unbelievable. But now I'm halfway through and the stories have become increasingly more ridiculous. It pretty obvious that many of the "abductees" are severely mentally ill, with hallucinations being the norm, and many many many delusions of grandeur. At least one patient suffered from obvious sleep paralysis, and interpreted this problem as him being stalked by some kind of inter-dimensional alien. It's understandable that the average person might not know what sleep paralysis is, and would try to come up with explanations for what he experienced. But the answer should have been obvious to the author, who was a psychiatrist. Instead of mentioning the possibility that the experience had a rational (and rather common) explanation, the doctor apparently went along with the patient's alien interpretation. This is a repeated problem with the book. Some of the things that happen have no apparent rational explanation. But others do, and the most obvious explanations often go ignored. Almost all of the stories involve some form of sexual abuse, some of it extremely graphic. One of the "abductees" describes an experience where he transformed into an alien and sexually assaults another abductee (a human woman). That whole chapter was the most ridiculous and unbelievable so far. Another woman had been terrified of sex for almost as long as she could remember. She loved her husband, and he was kind and patient, but she couldn't have sex with him without panicking and feeling like she was losing control. One of the memories that were retrieved with hypnosis was of her being vaginally and anally probed by an alien at the age of 13. This is not an uncommon theme in this book, but that story in particular really got to me. In one story, the patient started attending therapy because he believed that he had been sexually abused by his grandmother, who had certainly sexually abused his dad. His dad was a known pedophile as well, who had tried to abuse the patient's younger sister. The same patient said that the alien spaceship he was taken to as a child was his true home. Seeing as he came from a disturbingly awful family, I can understand why he would be desperate to belong anywhere else. The author repeatedly insists that his patients show no signs of being mentally ill, while contrarily relaying stories that are full of countless indications of mental illnesses. It's not normal to walk around a hotel room hallucinating, bump your head in the process, then claim that the experience was just the aliens' way of teaching you some kind of lesson (???). It's not normal to convince yourself that your newborn son is somehow an alien, with no proof whatsoever. And don't get me started on all the cases where the people were obviously sexually abused as children. I feel for the patients. I really do. And who knows, maybe some of them did experience exactly what they described (as in real alien abductions). The most persuasive stories are the ones where the abductees find out years later that their relatives had the same exact experiences as them. I still intend to keep an open mind, and to finish the book. But I am incapable of closing my mind to common sense in the process.
- nonfiction
Billy Vali
2 reviews
This book is outstanding! It really changed my perception of the whole abduction experience. The book is split up with each chapter discussing an abductee telling their experiences. The abductee undergoes hypnosis performed by John Mack a Harvard professor of psychiatry. Through the hypnosis, they give a kind of of firsthand experience of what occurred during the abduction. Each abduction was unique in their own ways. Whether aliens show up in a bedroom and take the person while the person is still in bed or a UFO pulling a person out of a car that is traveling down a road, just to name a few. The book goes into detail about how the aliens research humans by abducting kids at a young age and doing varies procedures to them throughout the rest of the abductee’s life. Each story seems to have a common goal. The aliens want to save planet earth by showing the abductees the future of earth becoming destroyed and creating human/alien hybrid babies. A must read for the believers & skeptics out there!
Jace Cookson
2 reviews
In interviewing his patients, Mack describes his approach as “listening without knowing, but with a willingness to explore.” Make this your mantra when reading Abductions. I don’t know what to make of this book. Neither does Mack. He is as baffled as I am and yet, through stories of alien-human hybrids and apocalyptic prophecies, there is something compelling at the foundation demanding serious attention. With all the expertise that comes with being a Harvard psychiatry professor, Mack has found their trauma to be sincere. The vast majority of these patients are otherwise normal, thoughtful, and well-adjusted people. They all report experiences that share uncanny commonalities. The only firm conclusion reached in this book is that something is truly happening to these patients. Asserting anything more specific would be dishonest. Mack makes no dramatic claims and remains agnostic on the nature of these "aliens." I found his suggestion that the phenomenon may be related to the shamanic experience particularly compelling. I hope to see that idea explored deeper in his other book. But if I have one takeaway, it’s that I really really really want to be abducted.
Ard
139 reviews15 followers
Over the years I have read a number of books on UFOs and abductions, and found this one to be one of the most important. Not only because the author/researcher is a Harvard psychiatrist, which admittedly adds to its credibility. But also because the various cases which this book describes gives the reader a careful and balanced impression of the intellectually challenging phenomenon of these encounters. Halfway through the book I found myself watching the film "Intruders" again, also a fair representation of the great many of abductions that appear to have been going on since decades. The only setback of this book, apart from that of course it doesn't offer a lot of answers, is that after a few case histories, the account gets a little repetitive. For an experienced reader of books like these it made it a little less 'fun' to read than for instance 'Communion' or 'The interrupted journey', but to a critical audience I guess this style could make it more persuasive. All in all, 'Abduction' may turn out to be one of the most important books in the genre.
- non-fiction psychology ufo
Mike S
385 reviews39 followers
This is a must read for anyone with questions about what might be behind some UFO sightings. If you think we may be being visited by alien races, this book will be thought-provoking to say the least. Mack comes across as entirely credible, methodical, extremely careful, and quite likeable. He couldn't have done a better job on what could have been a very easy to discredit book. Instead, his expert and careful handling of the subject resulted in a book that is entirely believable, an encyclopedia, an outstanding classic in the field. Anyone who finds this book interesting will probably enjoy the alien remote viewing books by Courtney Brown.
- non-fiction
Christopher Timmerman
34 reviews
"To search expectantly for a radio signal from an extraterrestrial source is probably as culture-bound a presumption as to search the galaxy for a good Italian restaurant" (McKenna 1991). Yes, the aliens, after performing cattle mutilations, carrying out hybrid breeding programs, expanding individual (or collective, a la morphic resonance) consciousness by love and spiritual terrorism are going to pull back their saucers and pyramids from our pale blue dot and reply, as one group, to the ancient radio transmitter with a "We are here, humans, we come without having observed you once and view you as equals. We know you are sophisticated..." Meanwhile, Cambodian and Indonesian Genocides, Forrest Gump, and Mary Jane are all sailing on boats called "continents", exhausting gases like hippos fanning shit over the shivering ice caps (because we knew they were cold, our asses raised like the engines on our boats -- surprised suns providing the most heat). We're digging for something in the bottom of the boats: Guts of rope, ball bearings and cannon balls. Surely, bent over so far, shitting constantly, there is no worry of being attacked...it is more surprising that one can shit in this position at all, in Downward Dog. How is this possible? And now one is close enough to eat the toes right off their own feet -- and still shitting! Yet shit is remarkably absent from this book. The aliens do not seem to be interested in that part of us, not like children, fools and tricksters are. Instead, they're interested in anal probing, impregnation and fleshlights to a faultless degree (because of their advanced spirituality). Unless if you're experiencing samadhi on a regular basis, there's a chance our little friends will whisk you away, if not this life, then another, and if not you, then a friend or acquaintance of yours, and likely their family. Since the grays can occupy different dimensions, it is hard to say the experiences abductees have of them corresponds to, well, exactly what they're describing. Likely, the aliens use these various traumatic methods of probing, implanting, cutting, impregnating, in conjunction with the catastrophic images, perhaps as the only means left to pierce, permeate or make porous the vast majority of people's crustier-than-crustacean egos (a crab is less egotistical than the normal human, which is probably why we find them tastier than ourselves too, while much consciousness in a dish will spoil it). After all, they're not abducting the Dalai Lama or any Himalayan monks, those conscious of consciousness, because they're already jiving with our shapeshifting guardians. "Those large black eyes" a monk might say, "are eyes to get lost in." Are you opposed to getting lost in them? What's the risk? Even they admit they're afraid of our emotions, our depth, we being dark souls who have carried the flame far from the Source. Those large, endless eyes, full of love, bigger than us, and yet, reflecting how far we've come. Are they you, a genetically dead-end humanoid, trying to recover something they've forgotten? Or do they admire this human difference for what it is, and are not attempting to retrieve anything (excepting some hybrid children that may or may not be for us when the world is wiped clean). What if your connection was stronger with one of them than with any human, and you missed the children you created with your alien wife or husband? You realized some dual identity to yourself, felt some purpose that needed to integrate these two halves. Mack says toward the end, "Writer and futurist Jean Does disgust arise towards the hybrid baby because it is other, the mother desiring it to be a different species, while also trying to integrate it into the human, or because it is a more primitive species, that has been forcefully integrated with the human? For example, Kafka's cockroach-man. In evolutionary theory, cockroaches are hundreds of millions of years older than the human species and a different phylum entirely. They experience the world in a way that is older than us, in a way that came before us, that is non-human, yet still continues to the present alongside us, our scurrying friends. To be the cockroach-man is really just to have our experiences superimposed woefully short over the cockroach's much longer evolutionary vision. "I'm nowhere near as ancient as that..."as we look and see our scuttling legs disappear miles away into the dark behind us. He stands in contrast to Lin from Perdido Street Station, the artist khepri, a human with with a scarab head. The Egyptians rightly understood these animal-headed humans as gods, as they represent the human hosting a unique intelligence, and the human is something that can support these different intelligences. The otherness of the hybrid may not be overlooked because of the above analysis; the "listless" hybrids even being a eugenic experiment in removing man's self-destructive, and therefore destructive, impulses...how is a parent to approach them with affection? They seem to point the way ahead for man's spiritual development, and though forced, perhaps that is all the decency we deserve, even according to our spiritual value, if we cannot listen to our dying Earth. Here's to the Pentagon releasing UFO documents before June 1st this year, and to the next Copernican Revolution, when we find out not only are we not living in the center of the universe, but neither is our intelligence. Here's to the displacement of our intelligence and the unfolding of Indra's Web in the West, to the destruction of false Enlightenments and to the creation of cosmic cooperation. Rhizomatic creep-spread I've gone,
Houston, at the Congress of the World Parliament of Religions in
Chicago in September 1993, commented that all myths begin with
a form of betrayal." It may be that aliens are abducting us, and whether or not are performing these traumatic experiments on us, know how to betray us. But is that it? Do they want us to view them as mythological beings at a later point in time? It seems, rather, that the woman who gets impregnated by the aliens or whose "seed" gets genetically modified beforehand, resulting still in the same outcome -- will she suckle the hybrid? They seem to be playing with our biological altruism towards related things -- "That baby is mine, but..." What? Of course, this isn't some chromosomal abnormality, this is the splicing in of another species, forced (re)entry, as the species is more advanced spiritually, abductees report feeling this, often claiming we were two species separated from the Source long ago.
And diversity training
With my telepathic wife
Over morning bread.
Ten lotus prayers before
Existential coffee
(The Every New Sunrise).
"That's fine!
Other then you anyway --
Dear, we'll make it."
Who are you again?
Ryan Beltz
43 reviews4 followers
The book delves into the narratives of those who have encountered non-human intelligences (NHI). Each account unfolds with an eerily similar archetype and structure, prompting contemplation: is this a shared mental phenomenon, a spiritual event, or a fusion of both? Mack tantalizingly grazes the surface of these questions. One intriguing aspect Mack touches on is the "hero’s journey" parallel found in these stories. Are these encounters part of a shared consciousness, or do they draw individuals into a transformative experience? Mack hints at a New Age undertone, a thread that would have benefitted from deeper exploration, especially in dissecting the psychological and spiritual layers. While the patterned storytelling occasionally dips into monotony, it paradoxically underscores the authenticity of these experiences. The recurring themes, while somewhat repetitive, suggest a broader connective thread—a testament to the phenomenon’s reality on some level. Overall, "Abduction: Human Encounters with Aliens" stands as a pivotal work, a beacon of insight and thoughtful analysis in a fascinating and often-dismissed field. Mack’s commitment to unraveling the complexities of this subject is both commendable and enlightening. An essential read for those intrigued by the intersection of the unknown and the human psyche.
In "Abduction: Human Encounters with Aliens," John E. Mack boldly navigates the controversial terrain of extraterrestrial encounters. Initially met with skepticism, Mack's work now, in 2024, appears visionary against the backdrop of governmental acknowledgment of unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP).
- the-unknown
Kaitlyn Blake
76 reviews7 followers
This took me FOREVER to read. It's not bad, but it's super dense. It's supposed to be an academic text and it definitely reads like one.
Emma S.
7 reviews
5 stars for the writing of the late Dr John E Mack, not for much of the content on / with his clients. Beginning and end portions with his thoughts were stellar, as well as some of his interspersed commentary in the subjects’ accounts / sessions. Otherwise at times it was harder to get through. RIP
Karson
192 reviews11 followers
I picked this book up after watching the Showtime series called UFO. The last couple episodes referenced this book and the author quite a bit. Dr. Mack was a Harvard guy. He was high up in the food chain and he became particularly interested in the abductee phenomenon. He ended up taking on about a hundred "abductees" as patients. This book contains the cases of about 12 or so of these clients. As a disclaimer, this is my first foray into reading about abductions, aliens, etc. I approached the topic with high doses of fascination and skepticism. I figured I would start with a book written by a guy who risked his excellent reputation to explore the phenomenon. First off, I appreciated aspects of Dr. Mack's approach. I liked that he resisted the urge to label the abductees as "crazy" and then be done with it. This guy was truly open minded to other people's experience of reality. Instead of disregarding abductees, he asked the question "what can we learn about reality from these people?" Dr. Mack was open to reshaping his own views as a result of his encounter with the abductees. I, personally, haven't met many thoroughly credentialed people that are willing to reconsider their own views/training so I appreciated Dr. Mack in that regard. When Mack looked closely at these cases, he found that many of the abductees had no behaviors, tendencies or views that would label them as unstable or unreliable. Instead, he found evidence of significant trauma that was in need of processing, so he put the abductees in a state of hypnosis and processed the trauma with them. Again, Dr. Mack knew what repressed trauma looked like and he saw this in the abductees. When Mack "relived" these experiences with his clients what he found appeared (to my rational mind) absolutely astonishing and absurd. His findings also uncovered a repeating story line. Some abductees simply experienced the float up to the ship with the tractor beam deal. Others remembered specific procedures. Others had a "kinship" with particular beings on the ship. Still others felt more of a closeness with the aliens than they did with human beings. Some remembered that they were actually part human/part alien and the abductions were just a reconnection with their true source. By the end of the book a common story line had emerged. Here it is: Once upon a time, human beings and E.T.'s came from the same source. Since then, we've gone our separate ways. Unfortunately, humans are killing the earth and E.T.'s need to step in to save us and our planet. How are the E.T.'s going to do this? By creating a hybrid alien/human race with an elevated/less destructive consciousness. Currently, human consciousness isn't broad enough to accept this truth. Luckily, there are hybrid agents already among us. They have forgotten their source, however, and repressed their purpose. Hence, the abductions. They need to reconvene with the mothership. I am fascinated and speechless. What else is there to say?
Elliott
377 reviews71 followers
Read
September 24, 2019I have high respect for John Mack and thus I leave this book unrated despite the fact that I don’t believe in his conclusion: namely that the “Abduction phenomena” represents a literal interaction between humanity and extraterrestrial intelligence.
I’m skeptical for five main reasons. The first is that there has not been any unequivocal evidence for a single abduction experience- which is something John Mack mentions early on- in the 50+ year history of the phenomena. The second is that with extremely few exceptions the typical abductee, even after “recovering” their memory of the event, cannot describe how they entered the spacecraft where the procedures are subsequently performed on them. The third is that reported abductions are down (https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bost...). The fourth is that many of the landmark cases have since been proven hoaxes. The Andreasson Affair was exposed as spousal abuse, Betty Hill’s subsequent career proved that regardless of what happened to her and her husband she was unable to distinguish between a lamppost and a flying saucer (being brutally mocked even within the UFOlogy community), Travis Walton’s famed encounter seems to have been a plot concocted with his brother’s help )https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4094), Stan Romanek (currently in prison for possession of child pornography) seems to equally be a simple charlatan. Finally, my own natural pessimism comes to play. I wish, wish, wish, wish, wish, WISH! that there are three to four feet tall grey skinned humanoids who are extremely technologically advanced and yet wish us well in the universe to warn us of our own folly. But I can’t. Our civilization is totally ready to swan dive off the cliff’s edge purely because we believe that giving the already incredibly rich and selfish more money will eventually make everyone’s life better. There’s no wise old man in space who’s going to save us at the last moment from ourselves.
Jack
Author8 books10 followers
I started reading this book mainly because I read Whitley Strieber's Communion and it was one of the scariest books I have ever read, but also because I am fascinated with the idea of aliens. At first, I thought I was going to enjoy this book thoroughly when it talks about how aliens not only push our perception of what is real, but it starts off fairly terrifying because of the factual and scientific data that is presented. You feel a lack of control and that you are going to be visited by aliens tonight, if you haven't been already in your life. But then you start reading more and more cases. All the cases become extremely similar, and they begin to melt into each other. There are few details that vary and you become desensitized to what is happening, and you stop caring. The cases lose their impact. It's way too repetitious. The parts that could be interesting or scary, are glossed over with too little detail given. While Communion goes over all the gruesome and frightening details while building suspense, this book just doesn't deliver the same thrills and instead becomes boring. Of course, this book is meant to be more factual and documenting. It is from a psychologist's view point, and of someone who is trying to help victims. Communion on the other hand seems to be more of a story, almost fiction besides the fact that it is toted as being factual. Reading the intro and the first couple of cases, would have been more than enough and I wish I would have stopped there rather than continuing on for the rest of the almost 500 pages.
Kyra Zopff
3 reviews
Had higher hopes. Mack doesn't possess, or perhaps overlooks what the general public finds tasteful enough to take seriously. This book could have gotten greater buzz in larger circles if more direction & attention was given. RIP Mack, you wrote the best of these abduction analysis books. Perhaps given more time and filtering things could have gotten really, REALLY interesting.
- post-undergrad
Susan
35 reviews5 followers
This is not a fictional book. It is a collection of stories from the files of a psychiatrist who has specialized in working with those who claim they have been abducted by aliens. They are fascinating stories. What is most fascinating is that their stories are so similar, though how they "interpret" their experiences are dissimilar. As a psychiatrist, John Mack feels that such people need to be treated carefully, not because they are dangerous people, but because they need to be able to tell their stories and integrate their experience so they can "go on." I won't tell you what Mack's position is, nor the details of the stories, but it is a fascinating read. My thoughts are, "what in society is causing people to have these experiences? What is out of balance that needs to be brought into balance in our society." No, I don't believe in aliens, therefore I don't believe in abductions, but what is "abducting these people's imaginations?"
Alex Tsander
Author6 books
This book is well structured, competently written, but full of self contradictions. Mack seemed to think that it was possible to distort a readers perception of his own "evidence" in the way he claimed that supposed "aliens" could distort perception of time, space and everything else. Those who "believe" already will fall for this but it doesn't stand up to sceptical scrutiny. I nonetheless recommend this to anyone with an undecided mind or who is sceptical, to read with a "one step back" attitude, weighing up what Macks "experiencers" are quoted as saying, what he says this "proves" and the general inconsistancies between the two. Read this book critically and you will discover that it dispels any notion that the events alleged "really" occurred. The inconsistancies in the "facts" (if we take them at face value) and interpretations are too numerous and too large.
Mark Hansen
20 reviews
Pure utter trash science. Mack, should have been removed from the university, his license revoked and the book should be banned. He repeatedly abuses his authority, and his patients, by insisting that what they report as dreams are in fact, and without one stich of evidence, alien abductions. He rationalizes, the lack of evidence, by saying that it not his job to collect it, only to report, he uses hypnosis to implant memories, then when his patients don't believe him, he finds reports of UFO's to convince them. All the time, it feeds his ego, and fills his pocket book. Mack is/was a cultish guru of the same ilk as Jim Jones, or the Baghwan Shri Rashneesh. Nothing more. Mack should have been arrested and jailed.
Mike
18 reviews6 followers
gripping accounts of late night abductions as recited by those under hypnosis. unnerving in a way only a non-fiction book can be, mack spares us of any agendas and tells us the extent of his research. those with an open mind and interest in the subject will enjoy this immensely.
Erendira
48 reviews
This book is definitely creepy because of the detailed, methodical approach the author uses to basically present pretty convincing evidence that we are not alone...!! However, after a while, the interviews seem the same and I got pretty bored by the middle. I didn't exactly finish the book! :{